Jump to research

Composed by

Profile picture

Anonymous Snake

Views

145

December 09, 2024

Weight Scale

The research process involved reading through multiple threads on Reddit, along with articles from PCMag and Consumer Reports to gather information on weight scales. The sources were directly related to the original query and held a fair amount of consensus on some aspects. However, there was also a wide variety of personal experiences and opinions shared, leading to some disparity in the recommendations, and hence, a level of uncertainty in the final decision. Nevertheless, the research yielded a variety of weight scale options, each with their own strengths and specific user recommendations.

Have an opinion? Send us proposed edits/additions and we may incorporate them into this article with credit.

Confidence

70%

Words

656

Time

2m 26s

Contributors

80

Words read

18.1k

Withings Scale (now Nokia+)

Withings Scale (now Nokia+)

Withings scale, now known as Nokia+, was a popular recommendation in the Reddit community. It has been praised for its accuracy and affordability. This scale is also capable of syncing with the Nokia Health Mate app and works with Apple Health. However, it is worth noting that while one user had a positive experience with this scale for three years, they were unsure if Nokia has altered the technology, hence recommending to look for up-to-date reviews.
Renpho Scale

Renpho Scale

The Renpho scale from Amazon has received positive reviews from users who have compared its readings to their doctor's scale, finding it to be consistently accurate. This scale is also able to connect to a user's phone, providing a convenient means of tracking weight. However, there was no mention of its ability to measure other body composition metrics.
Etekcity HR Smart Fitness Scale

Etekcity HR Smart Fitness Scale

According to PCMag, the Etekcity HR Smart Fitness Scale is their top pick for smart scales. It offers high accuracy, 14 tracked metrics, Wi-Fi connectivity for app syncing, and a rechargeable battery. However, this scale was not discussed in the Reddit threads, so it lacks user testimonials from those sources.
Mechanical Scale

Mechanical Scale

Mechanical scales were also recommended in the Reddit discussions. They are praised for their consistency and accuracy when kept in a consistent room temperature environment and on a flat surface. However, it's noted that these scales tend to become less accurate with use. To counteract this, the use of calibration weights was suggested.
Eufy Scale

Eufy Scale

The Eufy smart scale was discussed in one of the Reddit threads, but it received mixed reviews. While it was praised for its weight measurement accuracy, its body fat measurements were said to be inaccurate. Some users recommended not using the body fat measurement feature, and instead focusing only on the weight trend.
EatSmart Scale

EatSmart Scale

An EatSmart scale was recommended by a user who reported it being consistently accurate for over two years. However, this was a single recommendation and there wasn't much discussion or consensus about this scale.
Taylor Lithium Scale

Taylor Lithium Scale

A Taylor Lithium scale was brought up during the discussions, but it appears to be discontinued and may not be available for purchase. Despite this, the user who recommended it seemed to have had a positive experience with the scale.
WW Scales by Connair Digital Glass Weight Scale

WW Scales by Connair Digital Glass Weight Scale

Another scale discussed in the Reddit threads was the WW Scales by Connair Digital Glass Weight Scale. This scale received a positive review from a user who confirmed its consistent readings from day to day. However, like the EatSmart scale, this was a single recommendation and didn't receive much discussion or consensus. In conclusion, the most recommended scales were the Withings scale (now Nokia+) and the Renpho scale, but the Etekcity HR Smart Fitness Scale was the top pick from PCMag. The mechanical scale was also a popular choice for its consistency and accuracy, despite the potential for decreased accuracy over time. Other scales like the Eufy, EatSmart, Taylor Lithium, and WW Scales by Connair Digital Glass Weight Scale received mixed or limited reviews. It's important to note that everyone's experience with scales can vary, and factors such as the surface the scale is placed on, calibration, and consistency in use can all impact the accuracy and reliability of the readings.

Jump to top

Research

"https://www.pcmag.com/picks/the-best-smart-scales"

  • Smart scales are devices that can track various body composition metrics beyond weight.
  • The Etekcity HR Smart Fitness Scale is the top pick for smart scales based on a review conducted by PCMag.
  • The Etekcity scale is highly accurate, offers 14 tracked metrics, Wi-Fi connectivity for app syncing, and a rechargeable battery.
  • Other recommended smart scales include the Arboleaf Smart Fitness Scale, QardioBase X, and Withings Body Cardio and Body Smart Scale.
  • The Arboleaf Smart Fitness Scale tracks 14 metrics including body fat, muscle mass, and body water percentage, and connects with Bluetooth and Wi-Fi. The scale is also frequently on sale for less than $50.
  • The QardioBase X features highly accurate body fat percentage measurements, connectivity via Bluetooth and Wi-Fi, and a range of measured metrics including heart rate, muscle mass, weight, protein, and more. The QardioBase X also provides safe modes for pregnant women and those with implanted medical devices.
  • The Withings Body Cardio is one of the most expensive smart scales on the market and offers resting heart rate and Pulse Wave Velocity features on top of standard tracked metrics. The scale syncs with Wi-Fi and Bluetooth and can also show weather forecasts.
  • The Withings Body Smart Scale is an affordable alternative that syncs via Wi-Fi and Bluetooth and tracks weight and BMI. The scale supports up to eight users and connects with over 100 third-party fitness tracking apps.
  • Each smart scale offers unique features and functions at different price points, and PCMag recommends that users consider their budget and preferences before choosing a smart scale.
  • The PCMag team evaluates smart scales for accuracy, features, and value, and conducts independent tests using their own bodies to determine performance.
  • Smart scales can use different methods to measure body composition, such as bioelectrical impedance analysis.
  • Investing in a smart scale can provide a convenient and helpful way to track progress towards health and fitness goals.
  • The transcript also introduces the PCMag team members responsible for reviewing smart scales, including Angela Moscaritolo and Andrew Gebhart.
  • Angela Moscaritolo is the managing editor for consumer electronics and has written over 6,000 articles and reviews for PCMag. She has a background in yoga instruction and previously worked as an analyst focused on smart home and wearable devices.
  • Andrew Gebhart is the senior analyst for smart home and wearable devices and has been writing about tech professionally for nearly a decade. He previously worked as a smart home market reporter

"Eufy scale body fat completely useless?"

  • The Eufy smart scale is being used by a person in the discussion of body fat measurements using smart scales.
  • The body fat measurements of Eufy smart scale are said to be inaccurate.
  • The scale’s body fat percentage seems too high and does not change despite significant changes in weight.
  • The visceral fat reading provided by the scale is unreliable and flips at a certain weight threshold.
  • The user of the scale doubts the technology and wonders if it is a scam.
  • Another user suggests a FitTrack smart scale that reportedly gave consistent body fat measurements.
  • A user’s body fat measurements were consistently wrong on the Eufy scale even though his weight, muscle mass, and size changed significantly.
  • Some users recommend not using body fat measurements on smart scales and focusing only on weight trend.
  • Users discuss the importance of controlling variables when using smart scales for body fat measurements.
  • Variables that should be controlled include hydration levels, the time of day, meal consumption, exercise before measuring, and drinking coffee or alcohol.
  • Emotional states such as stress and anxiety can also affect body fat measurements.
  • Users suggested measuring body fat percentage using medical-grade equipment.
  • Users recommend switching to an “athletic” mode on smart scales for more accurate body fat measurements.
  • Some users suggest that the accuracy of smart scales in general is questionable.

"Best smart scale 2024 r/Reddit"

  • The title of the video is “Best smart scale 2024 r/Reddit”.
  • The video has been removed.
  • The video was posted 10 months ago in the r/betabattle subreddit.
  • The post received 17 points before it was removed.
  • The post was about finding the best smart scale according to the r/betabattle community.
  • There are no comments in the thread as they have also been removed.
  • The transcript does not provide any information on the best smart scale or how to choose one.
  • The transcript only mentions the title of the video and the fact that it has been removed.

"https://www.consumerreports.org/health/bathroom-scales/best-bathroom-scales-from-consumer-reports-tests-a2890804144/"

  • Daily weighing leads to weight loss and healthy habits
  • CR recommends bathroom scales that deliver accurate readings
  • Some bathroom scales are better than others at being consistent regardless of user’s weight shifting
  • Consistency in readings is important when selecting a scale
  • Time of day should be consistent when weighing yourself to get the most accurate weight
  • CR featured 5 bathroom scales that performed well in lab tests
  • Bathroom scales are tested for accuracy, consistency, ease of use, and balance
  • Accuracy is tested using a calibrated lab scale that displays the weight to the hundredth of a pound
  • Eight different weights ranging from 30 to 325 pounds are weighed and the readings are compared to determine accuracy
  • Consistency is tested by taking multiple readings of each weight on each scale and comparing them
  • Balance is tested by having the tester stand in different positions on each scale to see if the readings change
  • Ease of use is assessed based on the size of the numbers on the display, adjustability, and readability without needing additional lighting.
  • CR also provides a bathroom scale buying guide with more details on how to choose a good bathroom scale
  • The guide includes tips on weighing at the same time of day, considering features such as body composition measurement, and how to troubleshoot any issues with the scale
  • Haniya Rae, former reporter for Consumer Reports, wrote about consumer advocacy issues for The Atlantic, PC Magazine, Popular Science, and others.

"What’s a good reliable body scale?"

  • Discussion about a good, reliable body scale with Bluetooth/Wi-Fi connectivity.
  • Users report issues with accuracy on most Amazon scales.
  • One user recommends a Taylor Lithium scale but it seems to be discontinued.
  • Another user recommends a Withings scale (now Nokia+) that is accurate and affordable.
  • This scale syncs with the Nokia Health Mate app and also works with Apple Health.
  • Another user recommends the EatSmart scale, which has been consistently accurate for over two years.
  • Some scales require calibration which can help iron out inconsistencies.
  • Generally, basic scales tend to have accuracy issues.
  • The best scale is one like you see at a doctor’s office and some gyms.

"What are the best weight scales?"

  • The video discusses the accuracy and consistency issues of different types of weight scales, and how this can lead to varying readings.
  • The recommendation is to invest in a mechanical scale and keep it in a consistent room temperature environment and on a flat surface.
  • Using calibration weights can help maintain the accuracy of the mechanical scale.
  • Mechanical scales tend to be consistent when first purchased and become less accurate with use.
  • Two sets of calibration weights, one light and one heavy, can further help with maintain accuracy.
  • One user advises to find one scale and stick to it even if it is not completely accurate.
  • Jeans and other clothing can add weight and drastically impact readings.
  • Analog scales may not be completely accurate and may have some inconsistencies.
  • Digital scales tend to be more expensive than mechanical scales and offer a variety of features.
  • A user’s scale readings at home, their mom’s house, and on a new digital scale vary by as much as 10 pounds.
  • The user wears the same clothes in all readings and is working out and intermittently fasting.
  • The user wants to keep track of their progress while losing weight starting at 166 lbs., but they are concerned about the 10-pound difference across the scales.
  • A user suggests purchasing another scale to check which one is more accurate.
  • A user recommends doing an internet search to compare the accuracy of different scales before purchasing.
  • Another user notes that weight is just a number and urges the original poster to prioritize how they feel over the scale reading.
  • A user also advises against worrying too much about the scale and focusing on developing healthy habits to achieve their weight loss goal.
  • A recommendation is also given to weigh oneself at the same time every day for consistency.

"[deleted by user]"

  • A user recommends a Renpho scale from Amazon that has high ratings and is under $30, and connects to your phone. They state that their Renpho scale’s readings are close to their doctor’s scale.
  • Another user purchased the Renpho scale referred to above and confirms its accuracy against their doctor’s scale.
  • Several users discuss accuracy of scales, with some noting the importance of a flat surface and zeroing out the scale. One user states that very few scales are accurate to 0.1 lbs, even if they display that, and that any $20 model should be fine.
  • A user mentions that they prefer a good old fashioned manual scale that is not digital, while another recommends a scale with Bluetooth that automatically logs their entries into Apple Health.
  • One user recommends a WW Scales by Connair Digital Glass Weight Scale, that is rated 4.5 on Amazon, is $38, and is accurate to tenths. The user has weighed their cats and confirms the scale’s consistent readings from day to day.
  • A user asks which model of Renpho scale the original poster is referring to. The original poster provides a link to the Amazon page of the Renpho scale they purchased, stating that it is still accurate against doctor scales.
  • One reply is deleted and its content is unavailable.
  • The transcript includes comments from six different Reddit users in a thread on r/loseit.

💭  Looking into

Important factors to consider when purchasing a weight scale

💭  Looking into

Top 5 weight scales currently in the market for tracking fitness progress