August 14, 2024
Best budget 3dof motion platform
During my research, I reviewed discussions from various subreddits including r/oculus, r/simracing, and r/hoggit. I also visited a commercial website, dofrealilty.com, for information on a specific motion platform product. The Reddit discussions provided a range of opinions and experiences, with no clear consensus on the best budget 3DOF motion platform. However, a few models and DIY options were recommended more frequently than others. The commercial website provided detailed product information, but lacked user reviews for comparison. Given the varying opinions and lack of a single standout option, there remains some uncertainty in determining the absolute best budget 3DOF motion platform.
Have an opinion? Send us proposed edits/additions and we may incorporate them into this article with credit.
Confidence
60%
Words
566
Time
2m 22s
Contributors
80
Words read
20.5k
DIY Motion Platform
DOFReality HERO 3
Yaw VR 3DOF Motion Simulator
DOFReality H6/P6
Sigma Integrale's 4-actuator Kit
ERacingLab's 4 Actuator Setup
Jump to top
Research
"https://dofreality.com/product/universal/universal-motion-platform-3-axis-hero-h3/"
- The motion platform is called HERO 3 and offers three degrees of freedom (3DOF) including pitch, roll, yaw, and rear traction loss.
- The platform delivers an unmatched experience and a unique advantage with rear traction loss system that provides accurate understeer, oversteer, and drifting sensations.
- The price of the platform is $3,427 and payment plans are available at checkout.
- The platform includes a rigid metal rig, mounts for seat or sliding rails, integrated power drive motors, 100-240 control unit with USB, SimRacingStudio license, quick assembly tools, and a 1-year full warranty.
- The platform does not include a seat, VR headset, or controllers.
- The platform supports all necessary cables and motion software but not the games.
- The manufacturer provides 24/7 support and has been recognized as pioneers in crafting affordable motion simulators since 2014.
- The HERO 3 offers true 3 degrees of freedom and accurately simulates roll, pitch, front center for body yaw, and true side-to-side and front-to-back motion.
- The simulation of g-forces through muscle pressure points is possible by moving all controllers such as wheel, pedals, joystick, and monitor with the seat.
- The platform is ideal for customers seeking an immersive and realistic simulation experience.
- Compatible games include iRacing, Assetto Corsa & Competizione, Grand Turismo 7 & Sport, Project CARS 1, 2, 3, PRO, GRID 2, GRID 2019, Automobilista 1, 2, Flashout 3, rFactor, rFactor 2, F1 2011-2022, The Crew 1 and 2, Torque Drift, TrackMania 2, TrackMania Turbo, RDS: The Official Drift Videogame.
- Over 20 options are available for ordering including pedals quick release, HoneyComb A+B adapater, MagicBox for PS/XBOX, transportation wheels for 3DOF platforms, cables extension set for 2-3DOF platforms, SRS Hurricane Wind Package, and ProFlightTrainer Helicopter PUMA X.
- The FAQ section includes information on what is included in the DOF Reality platform, seat compatibility, and how motion compensation works with the platform.
- The company offers highly customizable Sim Racing Studio software that provides precise in-game feedback based on the car’s telemetry information, simulating
"Anyone interested in a very affordable 3DOF motion simulator for the rift?"
- A 3DOF motion simulator is being designed for gaming.
- The appearance of current motion platforms is often not suitable for a living room.
- The aim of this project is to design an affordable platform which would complete true immersion.
- The platform can be shipped easily, modular, expandable, and easy to assemble.
- Various motor configurations are considered, including servos or regular motors.
- The platform will have about 150° of pitch, 150° of roll and 360° of yaw.
- There are some possibilities of adding heave (up/down) later on.
- 6DOF is considered a bit of a blind alley, and 4DOF should be able to fake all six.
- The potential market for an affordable motion platform is huge when the normal consumers are able to afford such experiences.
- The project aims to create a basic form motion simulation chair at an affordable price.
- 3,000 people have pre-ordered Virtuix Omni.
- The typical consumer simulators run into the tens of thousands of dollars.
- At present, niche pro-sumer market good-quality 2DOF systems cost around £5k GBP.
- The homemade motion platform can be built for under $800.
- Traction information can be felt through the chassis as well as the steering.
- Motion platforms have not appealed to many people up until now, but with virtual reality, the demand will go up.
- The project creator follows the development of 6DOF joystick, which is almost done, and he became obsessed with the possibility of creating full-size motion platforms.
- The project creator wants to produce some sort of motion simulation chair for mass adoption that compliments “Presence” and gets much below the £1k mark.
- The project creator thinks if the demand elevates that much, it will allow him to create a basic form of motion simulation chair at an affordable price.
- The project aims for something in the $300-500 USD range.
"Motion Platform 3DoF - 750 kg (PS-3TM-750 v2.0)"
Not used in article
"Motion Systems - Motion platforms for simulators"
Not used in article
"MOTION FOR SIMULATORS - 3DOF MOTION PLATFORMS"
Not used in article
"MOTION FOR SIMULATORS - MFS"
Not used in article
"DOF Reality H3 Motion Platform Review By The SRG - Bsimracing"
Not used in article
"Products - DOF Reality"
Not used in article
"A Comparison of Budget Motion Simulators DOF Reality VS Everyone Else"
Not used in article
"Do It Yourself a motion platform simulator 3 DOF with Arduino Simtools (Simulateur dynamique)"
Not used in article
"My compact 3DOF Simulator"
- The two reddit users in the transcript discuss a DIY 3DOF motion rig built with the xsimulator community and controlled through SimTools software.
- The rig has the capability to move in sync with DCS.
- Xsimulator.net is suggested as a helpful source for those interested in building their own motion simulators.
- The website includes member builds and a glossary for acronyms used in discussions.
- There are also FAQs for DIY motion simulators that cover topics such as design software and dimension of sims, as well as PSUs, pots, motors, JRKs, Arduinos, and Motor Monsters.
- Commercial rigs and peripheries are also available for browsing on xsimulator.net.
- The community encourages research and planning prior to building one’s own motion simulator.
- Members also suggest starting a project thread and asking the community for help and advice.
- One user in the transcript discusses future plans to upgrade to a 6DOF rig.
- Another user expresses interest in motion simulators generally and asks for resources, to which xsimulator.net is suggested.
- There is a request for a DCS-specific video, though it is unclear whether this is relevant to the query.
"The 7 Best Sim Racing Motion Platforms For All Budgets"
Not used in article
"Model 710-3-2000 Three Axis (#3DOF) Motion Platform for Simulation #motionbase"
Not used in article
"3DOF Motion Platform for Home Flight Simulation"
Not used in article
"Can anyone tell me which is best for driving/racing? 3dof or 4dof?"
- Poster found dofreality.com which offers a 3dof motion sim for $1900 and asks whether it’s better than 4dof.
- 2dof is explained to be tilt forward, back, left, and right.
- Heave is explained to be going up and down and traction loss is when the back end kicks out and rotates around the front (like a car).
- 3dof is described as tricky, most being 2dof plus heave or plus traction loss. True 3dof is rare.
- 4dof is described as each corner being 3dof or 3dof plus traction loss which can be confusing.
- 6dof is the full flight sim type and is also great for cars. It’s described as a full 3dof plus you move forward, back, slide, left, and right as well.
- There are two types of motion sims: cockpit sims move everything (chair, pedals, wheels), and seat movers just move the seat.
- A home-made 2dof cockpit sim is described as the greatest thing ever.
- 3dof motion is described as roll, pitch, and yaw (traction loss) and heave (vertical movement) may be added as a 4th degree, which may be beneficial for flying and rally racing.
- The difficulty of adding heave is explained and if added to a 2dof, it’s commonly called 3dof with traction loss.
- A gekosystem chair is mentioned as an additional layer that can simulate G-forces.
- It’s suggested that if heave is desired with a budget motion sim, to start with 2dof plus traction loss (3dof). A 4dof motion sim may be more expensive than a 3dof.
- Speed is described as a consideration when choosing a motion sim. 150 mm/s is considered minimum for driving and flying needs larger travel but can be slower.
- The poster asks if the gekosystem chair is better than a 3dof or 4dof sim for flying and racing.
- A Reddit user explains that for flying, heave is more important and for driving, traction loss is significant.
- Adding additional components such as vibration ffb, speed dependant wind, button boxes, tachs, e-brakes, and using VR can enhance the experience.
- The poster questions whether a G seat can
"Look what I've purchased, 3dof simulator yay"
- User purchased a Yaw VR 3dof motion simulator, pro version with stronger motors and vibration.
- User intends to use it with Oculus Quest via link cable to play Dirt 2.0 and Flight Sim.
- The Yaw VR simulator can be connected to other platforms via its onboard position tracker via IMU Bluetooth.
- The design of the Yaw VR simulator has changed with vibration and LED at the bottom compared to the previous round design.
- Other users commented about the motion compensation of the Oculus Quest’s inside-out tracking and Yaw VR’s onboard position tracker.
- One user discussed wanting the racing cube motion sim but found it too pricey. The Yaw VR simulator the user purchased is also expensive.
- The SFX100 is a budget alternative to the racing cube motion sim. It can be built for less than $2k and has a more convincing platform (pitch/roll/heave vs pitch/roll/yaw) moving a more robust simrig.
"Motion Platform 3DoF - 750 kg (PS-3TM-750)"
Not used in article
"3DOF motion rig: 3 actuators vs 4 actuators ?"
- The discussion in the transcript revolves around choosing between 3 and 4 actuators for a 3DOF motion rig.
- There are diverging opinions on how many actuators should be used for a 3DOF rig.
- Using 4 actuators creates dependency between them while using only 3 doesn’t.
- Four actuators can support a heavier load.
- One user says that the only reason for needing 4 actuators is for weight limitations.
- The mounting options for 4 actuators are preferable to most rigs.
- A seat mover is discussed and may be overkill and make the rig too bulky.
- ERacingLab is mentioned as a source for a 4 actuator setup.
- One user likes the simplicity of 3 actuators for 3DOF, but four is preferable if 3 doesn’t have enough power to move the weight.
- Another user suggests that heave is definitely worth it.
- Someone mentions Sigma Integrale and their 6” 4-actuator kit with traction loss and surge platforms.
- Someone else recommends a DK2+ for a budget setup as it provides good immersion and practicality.
- The users in the comments share their personal experiences with different motion platforms and what they recommend.
- The discussion doesn’t mention budget much, but may be useful in determining the necessary or desirable features at different price points.
"3dof vs 6dof"
- “3dof vs 6dof” is a thread in the r/simracing subreddit, with users discussing their experience with both motion systems
- Some users state that the 3DOF is more realistic because it doesn’t tumble dry or create G-Forces
- A user clarifies they were thinking of a 3DOF motion platform that moves the pedals and the wheel, similar to reality
- A user explains that a 3DOF can only “tilt” and move you up and down, while a 6DOF can move you forward and backward, side to side, and yaw
- The same user thinks it’s obvious that anything less than 6DOF misses some essential forces
- Some users recommend the DOFReality H6/P6 as a cheap option for a full motion platform
- A user mentions that they think this platform doesn’t have the fidelity they desire, and they’re waiting for a rig with twice the platform footprint, size, and power
- Another user shares that they’ve added dampeners to the DOFReality H6/P6 to smooth out the movement and reduce bouncing back
- A user recommends the Sim Racing Garage channel on YouTube for in-depth reviews of various motion platforms
- The creator of the Sim Racing Garage channel has built their own 6DOF motion platform by combining two platforms.
Note: The transcript discusses general thoughts and recommendations for 3DOF platforms, and specific notes on DOFReality H6/P6 and the Sim Racing Garage channel. It doesn’t mention a specific 3DOF platform as the “best budget” option.
💭 Looking into
Factors to consider before choosing a budget 3-dof motion platform
💭 Looking into
3 affordable 3-dof motion platforms for gaming and simulation enthusiasts