Jump to research

Composed by

Profile picture

Anonymous Zebra

Views

74

May 31, 2024

best hiking socks

During my research, I visited several Reddit threads discussing the best hiking socks. The threads ranged from specific comparisons between popular brands like Darn Tough and Smartwool, to broader discussions about the qualities of good hiking socks and personal experiences with various brands. There was a significant consensus among users about the superiority of certain brands, particularly Darn Tough, but there were also varied personal preferences and experiences. Given the volume of discussions and the consistency of certain recommendations, I am fairly confident in summarizing the findings.

Have an opinion? Send us proposed edits/additions and we may incorporate them into this article with credit.

Confidence

85%

Words

534

Time

4m 9s

Contributors

455

Words read

58.6k

Darn Tough

Darn Tough

According to numerous Reddit users across various threads, Darn Tough appears to be the most recommended brand for hiking socks. The socks are praised for their durability, comfort, and the company's lifetime replacement guarantee. Many users agreed that these socks remained comfortable even after multiple washes and uses, with one professional guide attesting to the company's free replacement guarantee. Some users suggested specific varieties of Darn Tough socks, such as the full cushion hiking sock. However, a couple of users did note potential issues with the socks being tight around the ankle and abrasive. The composition of Darn Tough Hiker Full Cushion is 66% merino wool, 32% nylon, and 2% Lycra spandex, and they retail at $28 per pair.
Smartwool

Smartwool

Smartwool socks were another common recommendation, although they were often seen as a secondary choice to Darn Tough. They were noted to be a bit more expensive, but some users commented on the superior fit of Smartwool socks. However, there were concerns about the decreased quality of Smartwool socks over time. Some users felt that Smartwool socks did not last as long as Darn Tough socks, while others found them softer and warmer. The composition of Smartwool Classic Full Cushion socks is 66% merino wool, with a combination of recycled nylon, nylon, and elastane making up the rest, and they retail at $22 per pair.
Icebreaker

Icebreaker

Icebreaker was another brand mentioned by users, with comments on the superior fit of their socks and the convenience of having a physical store for replacements. One user in a separate thread suggested that Icebreaker socks have a policy similar to Darn Tough's warranty.

Other Brands

Additional brands were suggested by users, including Point6, DeFeet Woolie Boolie cycling socks, and Costco's own brand. Point6 was suggested as a preferable alternative to Darn Tough by one user. Costco's brand was highlighted for its affordability and nearly comparable wool content, with some users finding them soft, comfortable, and resistant to smell. Some users also recommended REI's store brand of silk liner socks. Other brands like Injinji toe socks, Fits, and Stance were mentioned as alternatives, particularly in the context of specific hiking needs or preferences.

Factors to Consider

There were several discussions about factors that can affect the durability and performance of socks. For example, foot problems or conditions, shoe and sock fit, laundering practices, and walking mechanics were all highlighted as factors that could influence how long socks last and how well they perform. The number of stitches per square inch was mentioned as a critical factor determining sock shape and durability.

Jump to top

Research

"Wool Sock Cost Comparison Specs and Cost per pair: Budget vs Name brands"

  • User bought an expensive pair of Smartwool socks from REI and decided to compare different options.

  • Specs and price per pair breakdown:

    • Darn Tough Hiker Full Cushion:
      • 66% merino wool | 32% nylon | 2% Lycra spandex

      • $28/pair
    • Smartwool Classic Full Cushion socks:
      • 66% merino wool | 25% recycle nylon | 8% nylon | 1% elastane

      • $22/pair
    • Kirkland (Costco brand) Merino Blend Socks:
      • 57% Merino Wool | 40% Nylon | 3% Spandex

      • $3.83/pair online | $3/pair if you buy in-store

  • Comparison of Costco brand vs name brands: 9% difference in wool content. Costco socks are comfortable and durable.

  • Users discuss quality, durability, and warranties of different brands

  • Darn Tough is recommended for hiking and running. Lifetime warranty and 90-day return/refund policy.

  • Smartwool has a 2-year warranty and 45-day return/refund policy.

  • Kirkland socks came with a “satisfaction guaranteed” refund policy but no warranty. Users suggest that they are soft, comfortable, and don’t get smelly.

  • REI brand merino wool socks are suggested as a cheaper option than name brands.

  • Users note that the number of stitches per square inch is a critical factor determining sock shape and durability.

  • Company reviews:

    • Filson has a lifetime warranty.
    • Patagonia and REI replace worn-out merchandise.
  • Costco’s return policy is noted to be beneficial: allows refunds if shrinkage is an issue or your jumper falls apart.

  • Users recommend making an economic investment in Darn Tough socks for long-term use.

  • Prices for Darn Tough socks may be reduced if bought on sale.

  • Users rave about how comfortable and long-lasting their wool socks have been, with some pairs lasting more than ten years.

  • Several Puget Sound-based companies have lifetime warranties.

  • Users recommend Injinji’s for hiking and Smartwool for running.

  • One user loves the Kirkland women’s merino wool option. They have found the men’s version too thick.

  • DeFeet cycling socks are long-wearing but not as rugged as hiking socks.

  • One user has switched to Darn Tough socks exclusively for daily

"[USA] Best Hiking Sock?"

  • The best hiking sock overwhelmingly suggested by multiple users is Darn Tough.
  • Users agree that the sock is highly durable and comfortable even after multiple washes and uses.
  • Many users highlight the lifetime replacement guarantee - a convenient feature.
  • Other brands include:
    • SmartWool PhD socks: Many users suggest SmartWool as a comparable alternative but note that it can be expensive.
    • Injinji toe socks: A user suggests pairing Injinji toe sock liners with Darn Tough socks.
    • Icebreaker: Users note the superior fit of their socks; they also have a physical store for replacements.
    • REI: Some users recommend REI’s store brand of silk liner socks.
    • Point6: A user suggests Point6 over Darn Tough.
    • DeFeet Woolie Boolie cycling socks: Another brand suggested.
    • Costco: A user suggests Costco brand hiking socks.
  • Users comment on their unique experiences with Darn Tough socks:
    • A professional guide claims that they stand by their free replacement guarantee.
    • A user suggests the full cushion hiking sock specifically.
    • Some users also suggest different hiking sock varieties that Darn Tough offers.
    • Two users have issues with Darn Tough - tight around the ankle and abrasive.
  • Several users talk about what activities or types of shoes are best for Darn Tough.
  • A few users suggest silk or reasonable liners.
  • There is several references to AT, or the Appalachian Trail.
  • One user suggests cycling socks as the best sock they have ever worn.
  • A user inquires on the best socks for a petite person, to which users comment on SmartWool’s fit.

"Really like these socks (smartwool phd light crew hiking socks for women) but they're sold out everywhere, any alternatives?!?"

  • Reddit users are discussing the best alternatives to Smartwool hiking socks for women, as they are sold out everywhere.
  • Some users recommend Darn Tough socks as everything one would need in hiking socks with a lifetime warranty.
  • Other users, however, had negative experiences with Darn Tough socks, including issues with fit and durability.
  • Some users swear by Point 6 socks, which they find to be just as good as Smartwool but generally cheaper.
  • Stance socks are also recommended by some users for keeping toes warm and are available in several designs.
  • Fits brand socks are also mentioned, with some users preferring them for their better fit compared to other brands.
  • The importance of avoiding fabric softener when washing Merino wool socks is mentioned by a user.
  • Darn Tough socks are said to offer slightly better comfort and texture compared to Smartwool.
  • Darn Tough’s lifetime warranty means that they will replace the socks if they develop a hole, however, shipping costs may not make it much cheaper than just buying a new pair.
  • Darn Tough socks tend to last longer than other brands, with some users reporting 5-6 years of use.
  • Smartwool socks are also mentioned, with some users having issues with durability, while others find them to last up to two years.
  • Some users have issues with the USPS shipping option for Darn Tough socks, which can take up to 14 business days.
  • Some users have had positive experiences with USPS delivering items quickly, despite its problems.
  • Point 6 midweight socks are recommended as being almost as good as Smartwool but without the premium price tag.
  • Point 6 Hiking Tech Light Cushion Crew Socks are suggested as a replacement to the Smartwool PhD Light Crew Hiking Socks, which are no longer available.
  • Stance socks are recommended for snowboarding.
  • Fits socks are recommended for daily wear, skiing, hiking, etc.

"Smartwool vs. Darn Tough"

  • The transcript compares two hiking sock brands, Smartwool and Darn Tough
  • Users in the transcript have used both types of socks, and many prefer Darn Tough over Smartwool
  • Multiple users in the transcript find that Smartwool socks develop holes more easily than Darn Tough socks
  • Many users comment on the superior durability of Darn Tough socks and the fact that they come with a warranty
  • Some users mention that Darn Tough socks have good compression and fit better than Smartwool socks
  • A few users mention that Smartwool socks do not wick sweat as well as Darn Tough socks
  • One user suggests using double-layered nylon dress socks with hiking boots, as they are very thin and dry quickly
  • Some users have issues with the sizing of Darn Tough socks, finding them to be a bit too small and compressive in some cases
  • Other users remark on the superior comfort of Smartwool PHD socks in comparison to Darn Tough socks
  • One user finds that the gold toe metropolitan in the largest size (10-13) works well as a hiking sock
  • Users discuss how to send the socks back to Darn Tough for a warranty claim and mentioned that the company accepts padded envelopes or boxes
  • One user recommends stuffing the socks in an Airmax envelope and popping the bubbles to avoid additional shipping charges
  • A few users in the transcript mention that they prefer Smartwool socks for running, while others prefer Darn Tough socks for hiking and skiing
  • Some users in the transcript mention that they have tried and been pleased with both types of socks and use them interchangeably
  • Users comment on the importance of socks for hiking and the impact of poor-quality or ill-fitting socks on overall foot health
  • Some users in the transcript have had negative experiences with both Smartwool and Darn Tough socks and have switched to other brands like Wigwam

"Darn Tough vs SmartWool - A review on Merino socks."

  • Comparing Darn Tough vs SmartWool vs Icebreaker merino socks
  • Darn Tough socks have lasted longer, stayed warmer, wick moisture, dry faster, and are better overall compared to SmartWool
  • Look for higher Merino %
  • SmartWool PHDs are top of the line
  • Darn Tough has a higher stitch count and a better warranty
  • Bridgedale takes a technical approach to materials and offers a lifetime warranty
  • Foot problems or conditions, fit of shoe and sock, laundering practices, and trail practices can affect sock durability
  • Choice of footwear and shoe fit, foot traits, and walking mechanics can influence sock and shoe wear patterns that in turn may also affect sock durability.

"darn tough vs smartwool socks"

  • Darn Tough and Smartwool are both popular brands of hiking socks.
  • Multiple users prefer Darn Tough over Smartwool, citing reasons such as durability, longevity, and fit.
  • Some users do prefer Smartwool for its comfort and padding.
  • The warranty offered by Darn Tough is highlighted as a selling point for the brand.
  • Users suggest that the quality of Smartwool socks may have decreased over the years.
  • One user suggests that Smartwool may be “burning the brand” by not maintaining its quality.
  • Smartwool socks are mentioned as being softer and warmer compared to Darn Tough.
  • Darn Tough’s arch support section is preferred by one user.
  • Multiple users mention that Darn Tough socks last longer than other socks they’ve tried.
  • The socks are discussed in the context of outdoor activities such as hiking, skiing, and biking.
  • Tips for keeping socks from getting lost in the wash are mentioned, such as using a lingerie bag.
  • Injinji socks are mentioned as being good for hiking in sandals.
  • One user suggests that Icebreaker socks have a policy similar to Darn Tough’s warranty.
  • A link to a GQ article is posted that suggests wearing socks with sandals is now acceptable.
  • One user mentions wanting Darn Tough to make toe socks.
  • Some users mention owning other brands of socks, such as REI and Stoic merino wool socks.
  • Some users mention wearing socks with sandals for outdoor activities.

"Smartwool vs Darn Tough socks wear comparison (with pictures!)"

  • The transcript contains a comparison between Smartwool and Darn Tough socks, two popular brands among hikers and outdoor enthusiasts.
  • Both socks were worn and washed about the same amount of times.
  • The person who compared them found that Smartwool wore out faster than Darn Tough.
  • Not all users agreed and some preferred Smartwool over Darn Tough.
  • There were discussions about the price of both brands, especially during sales.
  • Many users praised Darn Tough’s lifetime guarantee, which allows them to replace socks for free if they wear out.
  • Others felt conflicted about taking advantage of the guarantee if their socks lasted a long time.
  • The Costco brand merino wool socks were also discussed.
  • Users had mixed reviews about the quality of the current Costco socks.
  • Some users had good experiences with the older Costco socks, while others found them to wear out fast.
  • Some users recommended buying socks from Sierra Trading Post online for the best prices.
  • There were comments about the importance of sock seam placement and height for comfort.
  • One user asked if anyone had experience with wool socks from Costco, saying that they lasted a year, longer than any other sock they owned.
  • Another user agreed that the old Costco socks were good but said that the current ones were not as thick or cushiony.
  • One user found that Smartwool socks tended to stink after a while.
  • There was a discussion about REI’s return policy and how it has changed.
  • One user who returned items frequently was blamed for causing the policy changes.
  • Another user commented that REI may deny unreasonable or unfair returns.

💭  Looking into

The differences in material and design between different brands of hiking socks

💭  Looking into

Top 5 hiking socks based on expert reviews